[Archive]

Posted By: barry arnold

And what a resounding oppositional chorus it is!!!
Your fleshing out of the Magie,Doyle Nat'l nuance is, admittedly, very helpful. I appreciate your efforts.
The distinction between design errors and printing errors is pointed and
most illuminative. Also the element of intentionality with respect to the
Magie,Doyle Nat'l cases sings powerfully in your chorus.
I still wonder whether an error, be it design or printing, merits such singularity so as to gain position on the hallowed checklist.
Don't get me wrong. With Mr. Sloate, I have thought we have made a bit too
much of the various errors---and would simply enlarge his point to include
possibly the Magie and Doyle Nat'l. I would reiterate that I do appreciate
the errors and with Jim B find them cool, if you will.
I do have enough sense, hopefully, to respect and bend toward the resonance
and euphony of your chorus, as I continue to wonder.

all the best,
Barry