[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

Okay, here is my opinion, and again for the sake of discussion.

I know how to grade too, I've been doing it for 25 years. When I submitted the cards I made a mental note of what I thought they would grade, and that is: VG, VG, and VG-EX. Ultimately, after that third card was reviewed, all three of my assessments were correct, and I was in agreement that all three had their proper designation.

So why bring a mistake into the mix, just to muddy the waters? We both felt that the VG was incorrect, and the VG-EX was in fact the proper grade. So doesn't my own opinion (grading is no more than an opinion) count for something?