Posted By:
Peter_SpaethDo you REALLY think if I had (just by way of example) a PSA 8 Goudey Ruth, and I disclosed that SGC had rejected it, it would sell at a 90 percent discount? I don't for a minute. Indeed, and this goes back to where we started probably, I think most buyers of PSA 8 Goudey Ruths today recognize there is a possibility that precisely that has happened (or that the card used to be a 7) and don't care. EDITED TO ADD In my opinion people are buying the opinion of the grading service whose name is on the flip, period. Not some implicit assurance that the other grading service would see things the same way.