Posted By:
JohnI wouldn't bother arguing with the clown. If he is too ignorant to follow directions or read descriptions and oblivious to what a POOR 1 is, he shouldn't be buying on ebay.
If he emails you anything back, I'd simply write him back to refer to your terms. NO RETURNS on graded cards much less no threats of partial refunds, etc.
He's probably going to neg you no matter what you do so I would not give in and give him a thing. If he does, you do get to reply to it in your profile.
Also, how did he pay? In the event this clown wants to try and file a claim with paypal, save all of the emails, pics, etc... Have you left him feedback? He deserves a negative.
I wouldn't budge on it.