Posted By:
peter chaoThe deal has been completed. Pretty fair overall. I paid $550 and threw in 1959 Bob Gibson (in VG, unslabbed) and 1953 Bowman Whitey Ford (in g, unslabbed).
The Cobb with Bat Off-Shoulder is in a PSA 3 holder but looks more like a PSA 2. Making the deal was a lot of fun, thanks for all the advice. 
Peter