Posted By:
jay wolt"but it's mostly the fault of the seller and the grading company"
Don't think its PSA's fault, they listed the card as Henie Smith
and listed the sig as Elmer Smith, what else should they have done.
The seller should have listed both names in the title to avoid confusion.
Shoeless Joe did it properly when he sold it prior.
Here was his title in the prior eBay auction
"1909 T206 Heinie Smith Elmer Smith Autograph PSA/DNA"