Posted By:
EdMere character is NOT the issue. I appreciate good character as much as anyone.
But for HOF purposes, character is relevant only as it relates to the integrity of the game itself. Perhaps the Cobb-Speaker affair should have been investigated and disciplined more thoroughly. But the fact that he had a loathsome personality, often evidenced by off the field antics, should NOT be a reason to question his admission to the hall. Twenty four years of .367 speaks for itself.
Rose crossed the line. Steroid users crossed the line. These actions threaten the integrity of the game.
That said, give me 8 Pete Roses and a solid pitcher against ANY all-time team anyone can compose. Still, Bart Giamatti did the right thing.