Posted By:
Gilbert MainesIm sorry Matt. My response was directed to pre-war cards, which is the focus of this forum. I don't know why I did not realize that Mantle nor the set was post war.
It is my understanding that all post war cards must be slabbed to be marketable. So, if one company doesn't think your card is legit, try another. As far as "could PSA make a mistake"? I will leave that response to those more jocularly inclined.
Perhaps our marquee should state pre-war if that is our charter. "Vintage" invites any good intentioned wanderer to stop in and ply their inquiries.