Posted By:
mr. mosesis pretty obviously fake. Front surface appears to be non-photographic (no gloss or silvering)-the borders and corners show wear inconsistent with how it would actually look if it were in that well-used condition, the back is aged brown and dull (maybe even put in an oven) without exhibiting different SHADES of aging (no staining/spotting), and on and on. It surprises me that a dealer would offer three fakes at the same time instead of listing a few REAL cards in weak condition along with their fake. I didn't look at the other two cards but the Goudey has all the earmarks of not being real just from glancing at the thumbnail..... Just my opinion.
It's hard to make things fool proof
as fools are so inventive........