Posted By:
JohnBob,
I’ve been watching this for quite sometime about 7 yrs worth of auction watching and listings of both Demmitt & O’Hara. Actually the numbers are pretty close for both being offered, in some ways I have found O’Hara offered less.
But if you watch it comes in waves, a few of one then a few of the other. What I have found is the offering of the grades/quality of the cards. Most are heavily stained as you know, and very few if any are offered above VG at best. VG-EX to EX examples come up only once every few years, many times it has been the same cards. I think Demmitt pulls a bit of premium do to the fact that of the 2 he is the only card, which reflects the team change on his jersey in the card.
Those are just my opinion; I also have most of the images of the cards that have been offered if you’re interested.
Not to mention there is a very nice looking O’Hara up on ebay right now for about the same price as the O’Hara, which just sold via Huggins & Scott. However it is a much nicer card. FYI.