Posted By:
boxingcardmanAnd I don't know the other guy from Adam (sorry), but if your web site says:
"We guarantee all items to be authentic and will accept a return of any card or other item deemed not to be authentic by any reputable grading service. We cannot guarantee the grade any item we sell will receive by a grading service due to the inherent subjectivity of grading."
then you're dead in the water on this one. Take the card back and investigate it yourself, before this gets any worse.