Posted By:
T206Collector....is also that the card was trimmed. SGC only confirmed my opinion. These are only two opinions. But if you'd like to consider it not trimmed, that's cool, too. I am not sure why someone would trim a VG Durham with rounded corners. It doesn't seem to make much sense.
As Barry said, SGC Collector magazine has a very in depth article about how to spot trimming in T206 cards. It is quite informative. As I'm sure you know, given your years of experience holding T206 cards, trimming simply cannot be determined by stacking T206 cards on top of each other and seeing which ones run short. Check the Durham against the following checklist provided by SGC in that article -- none of which are outcome determinative, but must be used collectively to form an opinion as to the card. I have found that learning about trimming is done most easily when you are comparing a card that you 100% know to be trimmed against the following standards:
1) Wavy edges. Which, from your scan above and my own recollection, is pretty clear the top has a wavy edge.
2) Uneven corner wear. This one has even corner wear, so this would suggest no trimmed.
3) Parallel edges test. This one, more or less, has parallel edges, so another suggesting no trimmed.
4) Toning of the grain on the four borders of the card. My recollection is that the top toning is lighter (i.e., exposed to the elements more recently) than the other three borders -- suggesting trimmed.
5) Edge "roll." The top border of each card has a slight etching, appearing to be the top of a "roll" running across the card. This card does not have that, if memory serves me. Instead, the edges along the top form right angles on both sides of the card, whereas the remaining three borders do not.
6) Quality of Grain along the edge. The grain should be flat with no graininess or fluffiness to it. Upon close inspection, very faint striations or diagonal lines may be present. Fluffy grain can have a rough look to it and tiny holes may be seen in the edge. I do not recall the top of this card's grain quality.
7) Chipping along the edges upon inspection on the reverse of the card. When a card has been trimmed, the chipping disappears. I do not recall whether this card has chipping along the reverse top edge.