Posted By:
T206Collector....plenty of examples of SGC 60 cards with corners as rounded as the Willetts. SGC is consistent in its grading of such cards as 60's, as long as there are no other issues.
Your definition or expectation of VG-EX is lower than the industry standard. And, by the way, in the ten years of collecting I did before I collected graded cards, those were EX in my book, too.
This is the Lefty Grove I bought in 1989 as a 16 year old kid -- I bought it believing it to be EX condition, even with the corner wear. Sure enough, SGC agreed with me 15 years later when they slabbed it:
http://www.sgccardregistry.com/images.asp?cardid=512&usetid=1127