Posted By:
Neal Kane<<To all of those who have their collections in PSA, I'm sure you have pently of rationalizations for why stuff like this doesn't matter. I'm just glad I don't have to rationalize.>>
I don't have to rationalize either ... and I collect mainly PSA graded cards. I also own a few SGC graded cards, and that area of my collection is growing.
I do not the true story behind the card, nor do I care. PSA has graded a ton of cards. Many of them have been overgraded, many have been undergraded, and many of them have been altered and then slabbed -- I hear about those often. I would imagine that other grading companies have a pretty close percentage to what is over/under graded, as well as altered material that somehow got slabbed.
To post on how PSA got a grade correct would make some pretty boring reading. As far as my collection goes, PSA has gotten it right pretty much every single time.