Posted By:
AnonymousHere are the most questionable ones to me:
Pioneers/19th Century (?) - M. Bulkley (really it was Hulbert who did what Bulkely was originally credited with) Hulbert finally got in a few years ago.
Candy Cummings (almost certainly did NOT invent the curve ball) his stats are lame too.
Tommy McCarthy -- there are many better 19th century outfielders not in the HOF (e.g. Tiernan, Ryan, Stovey, O'Neil, Browning etc)
20th cent. players: in no real order:
Lindstrom, Marquard, Haines, Hafey, Geo. Kelley, Chesbro (1 great year), Bancroft, Stonewall Jackson, R. Ferrell (his brother was a better candidate), Schalk (not throwing the 1919 series is not a good reason and his stats are quite weak); Pennock.