Posted By:
PCClash vs. Ramones -- Clash by a mile. The Clash have better musicianship (to the extent it matters in punk), lyrics and intensity, across entire albums. In my humble opinion, the Ramones mailed in a lot of their material.
And I'm a Ramones fan, just have to be realistic in the comparisons to the Clash.
And I think The Clash pale in comparison to The Jam (the greatest UK band that most Americans never heard of). Paul Weller took the band in a very different direction after the first couple of records, but it is all great. If you don't have it already, pick up the Jam compilation "Snap". And their live record "Dig the New Breed" is also amazing ... they are very English sounding, which maybe explains why they never took off in the US the way they did in England.
But overall I prefer the American bands -- DKs, CJs (I was surprised reading through the posts how long it took before the Jerks were mentioned) and BF. And for more recent (meaning post 70s and 80s) punk-ish material, Social Distortion is great. I recommend "Somewhere Between Heaven and Hell" to all. What a great album.
Interesting OT posts here. And glad to read about yet more common interests.