Posted By:
DJI disagree. If we don't allow Clemens in, then we should simply close the Hall down and refuse to allow any more inductions.
It's impossible to separate who cheated and who did and what one thinks is cheating, another doesn't. While McGwire hides like a nancyboy (guilt?), Clemens hasn't been indicted in anything.
If closing the Hall is a bit drastic, then we should simply begin inducting those who didn't play during the juiced era.
You will have more like next year's class, players that can't make it during a good year, but can make it during a slow year. That makes no sense to me. If Goose isn't good enough to be in five years ago, why is he good enough in 2008?
DJ