Posted By:
Joe_G.JC, congrats on a great piece. I believe it to be one of the most striking 19th century pieces out there. However, I agree with most in that it loses much of its appeal if parted out.
The CDVs by themselves are a mixed bag (Barry's image at lower res).
With original matte, WOW !!
An 1873 Boston Cabinet, it's possible a cabinet similar to this is out there based on the Warren CDVs.
As a complete collection, it's a strong candidate for your most impressive piece. A CDV or two from it would blend in with your many impressive pieces.
Along these lines, if I or anyone could find Tomlinson Studio's original 1887 "Champions of the League" team composite with each Detroit portrait in full cabinet form, it would be of far more value (to me) as a complete collection than each cabinet by itself. Just my thoughts.
Best Regards,
Joe Gonsowski