Posted By:
Josh K.I would go with sgc simply because they will take better care of your cards - I wont say its never happened, but Ive certainly never had any cards graded by sgc come back with damage that wasnt already present.
I would also add that its a good idea to scan your cards b/f sending them to any grading company - that way, if something does happen, you have some proof as to the condition b/f they were sent.