[Archive]

Posted By: leon

There is really no rhyme nor reason between 1's and A's sometimes. Generally I think if a card has more than 1 issue it won't get a 1...and sometimes it won't get an A. I only have experience with SGC on these matters. Also, if it's normal wear and all of the card is there it should get a 1....but again, not always. I do think it's a little too much of a judgement call..even more so than grading numerically. As for the subject card of Wagner I think a 1 is the correct grade...though I would rather have a nice "A" than it. That's an ugly card....I am not sure even Jay B or Zach R. would like it