View Single Post
  #1  
Old 09-29-2006, 06:57 PM
Archive Archive is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 58,359
Default :::::===- - - - DOTS RULE - - -===:::::

Posted By: Anthony Clevamonte

but -

Even a kid can figure out that if you had to cut out the individual players from the strip last year, you do again this year, even if there are no dotted lines. But with no dotted lines, you have a choice of cutting down the middle between the players, or eliminating the white borders completely!

But once you move from strip cards to other multiple player cards, it becomes more difficult a choice. What to do?
For example, the 1935 Goudey four in ones, really can be cut apart. But they shouldn’t be. The reason I know that they shouldn’t be is because there is a puzzle on the backs of the cards, which would be ruined if the cards were cut apart.
But the 1941 double plays should be cut apart. The way I know this is because the manufacturer gave each half a separate number – so they could be cut apart. Otherwise why have two different numbers per card?
But beyond this elementary start to figuring out “what to do” I have no idea, and therefore presume that it was left up to each individual collector. Personally, Id cut them all apart. The exhibits were too big for my hands to start with, the strips are impossible to deal with unless cut, and as everybody knows, a card has to be sorta square to flip right.

I vote hack ‘em all up – except the ’35 Goudeys.

Tony (the Cleaver) Clevamonte

Reply With Quote