Posted By:
Dave SimonSo you send the card in and they won't grade it -- big deal. You can still sell it ungraded.
The other thing no one is mentioning is that PSA and the other companies have many exemplars of the cards they are reviewing -- did your expert have a control or any other known real Wagner's (exemplars) to compare it and the paper tests to? If so, great what were the results. If not, the analysis they performed is totally flawed an unreliable. Anyone could have done a reprint on older paper stock in the 1960's or prior to that.
The other question is why is there a difference in the specular highlights in his hair of a 'real' Wagner and your copy?