Posted By:
Hal LewisNo doubt.
If the "Just So" Cy Young card is legit...
then it would be his rookie card.
UNTIL...
someone takes an old image of Cy Young and a real Old Judge card and sends them to the professional restorers to CREATE an 1890 Old Judge rookie card of Cy Young.
I am just VERY skeptical of a lot of these "mystery" collectors who have some fabulous items but don't want them slabbed and authenticated.
It just sounds pretty "hokey" that someone can own a baseball card that is worth $100,000...
which means that it is probably INSURED...
and I don't think insurance companies are real keen on insuring pieces of cardboard for $100,000 without having them AUTHENTICATED.