Posted By:
Andy BaranHal,
I'm not questioning the importance of the Reccius Wagner or the importance of the E107 Wagner. The importance of the E107 Wagner is not affected by whether or not you or others consider it to be a Rookie Card. It's significance is that it is the most important player from what many consider to be the most important post 1900 set.
Both of the Wagner cards can be considered Rookie Cards, depending on one's own definition. I stated earlier that this is subjective. My only point was that if someone considers the Reccius Wagner to be a Rookie Card (which it very well may be), then the Just So Cy Young (which is definitely real) has to also be considered a Rookie Card. If you choose to consider the E107 Young to be a Rookie Card, then the E107 Wagner is as well. I just don't see a grey area here. It is black & white.