Posted By:
Andy BaranHal,
If you consider the Henry Reccius Wagner to be Wagner's Rookie Card, then you really can't consider the E107 Breisch Williams Cy Young to be Young's Rookie Card (as you do on your website). The Just So Tobacco Young is every bit as legitimate (and probably more so, since it is from a set) than the Reccius card. The fact that you don't own the Just So Young is not a sufficient enough answer to ignore it. I think you need to continue to search for an E107 Breisch Williams Wagner to hedge your bets. If the E107 Cy Young is a Rookie Card, then so is the E107 Honus Wagner.