Posted By:
Frank WakefieldNeither...
Here's a link to a Wikipedia article that seems to fairly explain the deal with Fatty...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fatty_Arbuckle
And, I think Jay's correct. Many folks with Arbuckle cards would have pitched them out, with disgust. Hence the shortage. Plus it is an odd card, and maybe his only card, altough I have some sort of card of him that might have been part of a candy box, I'll try to scan it, post it, and see if anyone can identify it.
Frank.