View Single Post
  #5  
Old 05-18-2006, 02:13 AM
Archive Archive is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 58,359
Default Does this Goodwin Keefe look legit?

Posted By: fkw

Dont know why you think its a fake?

Top one Looks good to me in every way. I bid but it went over my snipe.

The dark staining front and back and stuck white paper (or paper lose) on bottom left is 100% in line, and the surface wear (tiny white spots) on front and on right edge of picture and surface wear to the back and the corner wear looks 100% OK too. The 2 cracks at top right side near the big white dot looks OK too and consistant with this issue. Surface chipping (large and small dots of white) is a problem with this issue.


IMO I think the Library of Congress card has too much yellow color to the scans.

Here is another one that is SGC-50, next to the one on eBay tonight. All scanners and scans are slightly different.


Frank

Reply With Quote