Posted By:
Harry Wallace (HW)I think that they are both great examples and would love to have either of them in my collection.
Personally, I would take the one with the stain on the back because I like the look of the the front better, but I think that the VG 3 example will sell for more than the EX 5 ST because the people who collect graded cards sometimes shy away from cards with qualifiers.
I would also say that I would prefer to have either of these examples than the last one that was aucitoned off that was small and and the wavy cut.