Posted By:
JimBCorey,
Just to clarify on the Doyle card, SGC did pay damages to a subsequent purchaser: Alan Rosen. He bought the card in an SGC holder without looking closely at it. He was not the one who submitted it to SGC. His argument was that he trusted the authenticity of the card based on the assessment of SGC. On that basis, SGC paid him for the card (I forget the exact amount.).
JimB