Posted By:
Al CrisafulliJeff, in my case, it depends on the card and why I own it.
In the case of 1938 Goudey, I'm trying to build the set in as high grade as possible. If I spend $500 for a raw Hank Greenberg that I think deserves a 6, and it comes back a 4, I'm going to resubmit it over and over and over. The difference between a 4 and a 6 in value is hundreds of dollars.
In the case of some other card where I'm not as condition sensitive, then it depends on what the card is and whether I can live with the grade. If the difference in value between the grade I think the card deserves and the grade it got is a big difference, I'll resubmit. If not, I'll live with the grade.
And BTW, I always send back the flips, in a different package, not with my submissions. I usually wait until I have a whole bunch, though.
-Al