[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

I think part of the reason that the E97 Young is accepted as Cy is other than the fact that Irv is left-handed, there is some vague resemblance to the portly Cy and collectors have only identified this error recently. What if you had a card that pictured Brooks Robinson but was captioned Jackie Robinson? Might collectors view this differently? In the case of the Weaver/Tinker error, you can't even see the player's face, so who cares?