[Archive]

Posted By: John J. Grillo

I really do not see how you can go wrong with either PSA, SGC, or GAI. I think the resale value difference (if there is a difference) with PSA would be minimal for this set...I do not think it should be a factor in your decision imo. All 3 are solid. Some like the simplicity of the PSA holder, some like the Black borders with the SGC and GAI slabs.

If it was me, I would select either GAI or SGC in that order. But my main reason is that GAI and SGC provide more descriptive labeling (i.e. Catalog #, Year issued, Tobacco Company, variations, etc) then PSA. GAI does provide a label on the top flip which makes pulling cards out of a set for viewing easier if you keep them in a storage box.

Good luck on your decision