Posted By:
DJIn 2001, I had a 1991 Upper Deck Extended Edition case sitting in my garage and noticed that PSA10 Pedro Martinez rookies were bringing $200-300. I was like "Wow, for a $15 card, not bad!".
So I ripped open the case and removed the 60 Pedro Martinez cards and went through them basically with a fine comb spending roughly a minute on each card making sure there were no imperfections whatsoever.
Well I sent the five best to PSA and what came back were (1) PSA9, (3) PSA8 and (1) PSA7. Safe to say I was disappointed and unhappy at the fact that I was disappointed in the grade and lost money as the PSA8's sold for about $20 each.
DJ