Posted By:
Peter SpaethI think it would be very hard to prove fraud on the Plank sale. One, whether it is trimmed is a matter of opinion, not fact. Two, the seller did not represent the card was not trimmed, he represented that PSA had graded it a 3, which it had. Three, whoever bought it is likely a sophisticated purchaser who was not relying on the seller's opinion. If I were a plaintiff's lawyer (god forbid lol) I think my best case might be that the seller omitted to disclose a material fact, namely that Hunt's had sold the card as probably trimmed (or whatever they said), but that said I don't think it would be a particularly strong claim.