Posted By:
identify7A GAI4 Pfeffer sold on eBay last night for $204. The image was crisp, back clean, corners rounded.
I consider that a favorable price for the buyer.
Your Pfeffer, (if the scan isn't misleading), has a trapezoidal cut with the image cocked on the card, in addition to the back damage. If I was the seller, I would think that my card could get >$125 in the SGC1.5 holder. Because the cut and cocking and residue really ain't that bad. imho.
The McCarthy, although possessing great eye appeal, may have difficulty achieving $100. imho.