Posted By:
Tim NewcombDanny,
It's up to you, of course, but if the card is a reprint I wouldn't keep it for any price.
On the other hand--
If you thought it was authentic but trimmed, that would be a different story-- then anywhere from 10-50% of the untrimmed price might be reasonable, depending on scarcity.
The seller will refund (or at least he did for me)--
Tim