[Archive]

Posted By: John J. Grillo

If I am going simply by aesthetics, the bvg is the most attractive, secure holder imo and they are by far the toughest grader on modern issues.

Overall though, I would give a slight edge to SGC over PSA in vintage cards. The SGC label is the most detailed/descriptive while PSA for example omits the tobacco manufacturer from T-205/6/7 cards. My vintage card collection is approximately 60% psa and 40% sgc.