Posted By:
Hal LewisJoe made a very good point.
The card that I have of McCarthy is one of his 1887 Philadelphia poses (even though PSA labeled it as "St. Louis").
These are his true rookie cards and are not as common as the other OJ's of him.
If anyone can show me more than TWO of these 1887 "Phil." cards of McCarthy that have been graded higher than mine...
then I will gladly change my web site.