[Archive]

Posted By: Greg Ecklund

1. Babe Ruth (1920-24)
2. Lou Gehrig (1930-1934)
3. Rogers Hornsby (1921-1925)
4. Ty Cobb (1909-1913)
5. Willie Mays (1961-1965)

* Barry Bonds (2000-2004)

I consider Bonds a cheater, but he has to be included in the discussion - I don't want to turn into another Bonds thread however. Under normal circumstances, I'd put him 2nd or 3rd.