[Archive]

Posted By: jay behrens

No brainer in the pitching department, Koufax. As someone else mentioned, that debate has been reharshed enough, no need for anyone to some to his defense. Those of us that think is overrated have pretty much made up our minds, as have those that think he was the greatest pitcher since the curve ball was invented. This doesn't mean that he doesn't belong in the HOF. It jsut means that he is incredicly overrated.

Hitting, I too would go with Big Mac. Strictly a one trick pony and that one trick is well represented already in the HOF. And at least Killebrew was capable of a few other positions in his career before finally ending up at 1B. Besides, can you seriously consider someone for the HOF that spent a season struggling to stay above the Mendoza line?

Jay

My place is full of valuable, worthless junk.