[Archive]

Posted By: Wesley

That's a tough call Josh. I think most of the responses you get here will say that you need to disclose the SGC results. But I am positive that this is not the first time a card has been rejected by one grading company and encapsulated by another. This is NEVER mentioned in any ebay descriptions or autionhouse descriptions.

What if instead the card was graded and SGC encapsulated the card in a 4 holder? When it comes time to sell, are you obligated to disclose that the card was once deemed only PSA 3? For this hypothetical, I would say you are not obligated to disclose that one grader previously graded it lower. Your situation is different but I would still say the answer is no.