Posted By:
Josh K.Well, the bad news came today - SGC did not grade the card - evidence of trim. When I called them, they stated that both the top and bottom concerned them (despite the fact that the card measures correctly). They stated that the cut on those edges was flat/square and not rolled as they would expect to see. Other than that, I was not given any definitive reason for their conclusion.
So, not really being interested in a trimmed card in a psa holder, what are my options? Ive contacted the seller who refused to accept a return (states the card was consigned and the owner already paid).
If I sell it, would it be unethical to simply list it w/o disclosing that it was rejected by SGC (but of course answer any direct inquiries honestly)?