Posted By:
RunscottRunscott's computer is acting up but here are his thoughts:
First, the box is for "Honus Wagner" 10 cent cigars, not "Henry Reccius" cigars - quite possibly two different companies. If these two items are going to be tied together as from the same period, you should want to see "Henry Reccius" somewhere on the cigar box.
Second, it is also significant that the cigar box product is a "Honus Wagner 10 cent cigar" and the Henry Reccius trade card is for a "Hans Wagner 5 cent cigar". Seems if they were made by the same company they would be either "Hans" or "Honus", not both. In fact, the Reccius card doesn't mention a "Honus Wagner 10 cent" cigar anywhere, but advertises several other cigars that they make. Important: "Henry Reccius" is a brand, "Hans Wagner" is the company. What company made the cigar box cigars?
Third, the trade card has "Louisville,KY" as the location of the "Hans Wagner" company (manufacturers of the Reccius cigar). Makes sense that they would advertise using a famous person from their city.
Fourth - you should be able to date the Reccius card to a more specific range by using the manufacturer location and phone number, and lithography and printing characteristics.
I never agreed with Hal that this trade card came in a cigar box - thought it more likely that it sat in a stack on a tobacconists' counter. It's also possible that whoever manufactured the box got hold of a trade card and modeled their advertising after it.