Posted By:
Marc S.General thoughts:
On an 8x10, if a corner is bent, and not creased - can't the bend just go away?
Re: Steve Grad comments. This will essentially amount to 'he said/she said'. Under such a premise - I can't see where PSA/DNA has any liability here, unless they assert that they did not see the lot [which I cannot envision that they ever will do].
I'm not sure what the amount of damanges are here.
4% smeared signatures = value equals $800, assuming normal distribution
1.7% smaller than 8x10. Even if worthless, only worth $300, but surely they still have value.
And the condition...I guess it depends on how a legal entity would describe condition. I can't imagine that they would place a huge discount on a color glossy 8x10 that has a bent corner. A tear or something, sure, but this seems a bit over the top....