[Archive]

Posted By: Rhett Yeakley

Steve, I don't think that the posters on this thread are being overly negative towards you at all. In fact, I think many people were praising the fact that you provide good scans and have a good return policy. While grading is always a subjective thing, nobody is going to be happy with anothers grading all the time. I (and many others on this board) tend to look at pictures of items we are interested in rather than paying too much attention to a technical grade. What it boils down to for me is if I see something that I like I will buy it for a price I think is fair based on what "grade" I would give it. The only time condition comes into play (for me) is when purchasing a large group of cards. If that is the case one should ask for a "representative" card from the different conditions of cards in the lot, and then judge for themselves. I have never gotten too hooked up on technical grades, but that is my 2-cents.
-Rhett