Posted By:
barrysloateRob,
I'm with you all the way. I just emailed the seller and told him that too many uniforms (fireman, policeman, sailor) look like baseball and without bat and ball it's a very long stretch. I agree the Pearsall is unconfirmed though intriguing, but I'm one who believes that the half plate dag does picture six Knickerbockers. Both Cartwright and Duncan Curry are confirmed, Adams is postulated as a third, and since all six are wearing straw hats (which were worn by the Knicks) there is enough circumstantial evidence to suggest it is correctly attributed. There will of course be some doubt since at least three who posed are unidentified and may never be.