[Archive]

Posted By: MW

Gil,

It appears the seller was/is genuinely ignorant about the factor that condition plays in determining the value of a baseball card or piece of sports memorabilia. I would try to reason with them as best I could and if some sort of financial compensation were not given, a negative would not be unreasonable. After you leave a negative, however, it will probably preclude any further negotiation or financial compensation from the seller.