Posted By:
warshawlaw"It seems the card was rolled out. There was still evidence of the tear or flap on the back as well."
You elected not to reveal this to Wayne? As I read it, you owe Wayne an apology and an explanation and should probably buy it back for whatever he paid you.
MW, as far as California law goes, you have the right statute but the wrong locale. The transaction in question took place entirely in Cleveland, so Ohio law is likely to apply to it because the contract was formed and performed in Ohio.