Posted By:
Judge DredI'd give the edge to Schilling - Didn't Santana have a weaker record against winning teams. I know he was fairly dominant over the weaker teams.
Vlad's last few weeks and the Angels rise pushes him over the top.
Bonds - wow, if he doesn't get the MVP you know he must have alienated a few writers because NOBODY is even close. Without Bonds the Giants could have been the Diamondbacks.
Clemens or Oswalt? Clemens sure did put up some better numbers (better ERA, better win % and lower opp BA and more K's) but Oswalt put up 20. Let sanity prevail - go with Clemens.