Posted By:
John HarrellMike,
I have picked up a number of old bats with tape. If the bat is cracked for sure and needs repair, I usually remove the tape. If the bat is solid, I leave the tape, unless it is really ratty. Removing the tape means a further step, like removing the old tape adhesive (alcohol and elbow grease normally works), and then you face the issue of discoloration under the tape or uneven patina. All things being equal, you're probably better off leaving the tape alone.
John